/ 
Path-IsDev-1.001003
River stage two • 3 direct dependents • 21 total dependents
/ Path::IsDev

NAME

Path::IsDev - Determine if a given Path resembles a development source tree

VERSION

version 1.001003

SYNOPSIS

use Path::IsDev qw(is_dev);

if( is_dev('/some/path') ) {
    ...
} else {
    ...
}

DESCRIPTION

This module is more or less a bunch of heuristics for determining if a given path is a development tree root of some kind.

This has many useful applications, notably ones that require behaviours for "installed" modules to be different to those that are still "in development"

FUNCTIONS

debug

Debug callback.

To enable debugging:

export PATH_ISDEV_DEBUG=1

is_dev

Using an import'ed is_dev:

if( is_dev( $path ) ) {

}

Though the actual heuristics used will be based on how import was called.

Additionally, you can call

Path::IsDev::is_dev

without importing anything, and it will behave exactly the same as if you'd imported it using

use Path::IsDev qw( is_dev );

That is, no set specification is applicable, so you'll only get the "default".

UNDERSTANDING AND DEBUGGING THIS MODULE

Understanding how this module works, is critical to understand where you can use it, and the consequences of using it.

This module operates on a very simplistic level, and its easy for false-positives to occur.

There are two types of Heuristics, Postive/Confirming Heuristics, and Negative/Disconfirming Heuristics.

Positive Heuristics and Negative Heuristics are based solely on the presence of specific marker files in a directory, or special marker directories.

For instance, the files META.yml, Makefile.PL, and Build.PL are all Positive Heuristic markers, because their presence often indicates a "root" of a development tree.

And for instance, the directories t/, xt/ and .git/ are also Positive Heuristic markers, because these structures are common in perl development trees, and uncommon in install trees.

However, these markers sometimes go wrong, for instance, consider you have a local::lib or perlbrew install in $HOME

$HOME/
$HOME/lib/
$HOME/perl5/perls/perl-5.19.3/lib/site_perl/

Etc.

Under normal circumstances, neither $HOME nor those 3 paths are considered dev.

However, all it takes to cause a false positive, is for somebody to install a t or xt directory, or a marker file in one of the above directories for path_isdev($dir) to return true.

This may not be a problem, at least, until you use Path::FindDev which combines Path::IsDev with recursive up-level traversal.

$HOME/
$HOME/lib/
$HOME/perl5/perls/perl-5.19.3/lib/site_perl/

find_dev('$HOME/perl5/perls/perl-5.19.3/lib/site_perl/') # returns false, because it is not inside a dev directory

mkdir $HOME/t

find_dev('$HOME/perl5/perls/perl-5.19.3/lib/site_perl/') # returns $HOME, because $HOME/t exists.

And it is this kind of problem that usually catches people off guard.

PATH_ISDEV_DEBUG=1 \
    perl -Ilib -MPath::FindDev=find_dev \
    -E "say find_dev(q{/home/kent/perl5/perlbrew/perls/perl-5.19.3/lib/site_perl})"

...
[Path::IsDev=0] + ::Tool::Dzil => 0 : dist.ini does not exist
[Path::IsDev=0] + ::Tool::MakeMaker => 0 : Makefile.PL does not exist
[Path::IsDev=0] + ::Tool::ModuleBuild => 0 : Build.PL does not exist
[Path::IsDev=0] + ::META => 0 : META.json does not exist
[Path::IsDev=0] + ::META => 1 : META.yml exists
[Path::IsDev=0] + ::META => 1 : /home/kent/perl5/META.yml is a file
[Path::IsDev=0] + ::META matched path /home/kent/perl5
/home/kent/perl5

Whoops!.

[Path::IsDev=0] + ::META => 1 : META.yml exists
[Path::IsDev=0] + ::META => 1 : /home/kent/perl5/META.yml is a file

No wonder!

rm /home/kent/perl5/META.yml

PATH_ISDEV_DEBUG=1 \
    perl -Ilib -MPath::FindDev=find_dev \
    -E "say find_dev(q{/home/kent/perl5/perlbrew/perls/perl-5.19.3/lib/site_perl})"

...
[Path::IsDev=0] Matching /home/kent/perl5
...
[Path::IsDev=0] + ::TestDir => 0 : xt does not exist
[Path::IsDev=0] + ::TestDir => 1 : t exists
[Path::IsDev=0] + ::TestDir => 1 : /home/kent/perl5/t is a dir
[Path::IsDev=0] + ::TestDir matched path /home/kent/perl5
/home/kent/perl5

Double whoops!

[Path::IsDev=0] + ::TestDir => 1 : t exists
[Path::IsDev=0] + ::TestDir => 1 : /home/kent/perl5/t is a dir

And you could keep doing that until you rule out all the bad heuristics in your tree.

Or, you could use a negative heuristic.

touch /home/kent/perl5/.path_isdev_ignore

PATH_ISDEV_DEBUG=1 \
    perl -Ilib -MPath::FindDev=find_dev \
    -E "say find_dev(q{/home/kent/perl5/perlbrew/perls/perl-5.19.3/lib/site_perl})"
...
[Path::IsDev=0] Matching /home/kent/perl5
[Path::IsDev=0] - ::IsDev::IgnoreFile => 1 : .path_isdev_ignore exists
[Path::IsDev=0] - ::IsDev::IgnoreFile => 1 : /home/kent/perl5/.path_isdev_ignore is a file
[Path::IsDev=0] - ::IsDev::IgnoreFile excludes path /home/kent/perl5
[Path::IsDev=0] no match found
...
[Path::IsDev=0] Matching /
...
[Path::IsDev=0] no match found

Success!

[Path::IsDev=0] - ::IsDev::IgnoreFile => 1 : .path_isdev_ignore exists
[Path::IsDev=0] - ::IsDev::IgnoreFile => 1 : /home/kent/perl5/.path_isdev_ignore is a file

HEURISTICS

Negative Heuristics bundled with this distribution

Just remember, a Negative Heuristic excludes the path it is associated with

Positive Heuristics bundled with this distribution

HEURISTIC SETS

Heuristic Sets Bundled with this distribution

  • Basic - The basic heuristic set that contains most, if not all heuristics.

ADVANCED USAGE

Custom Sets

Path::IsDev has a system of "sets" of Heuristics, in order to allow for pluggable and flexible heuristic types.

Though, for the vast majority of cases, this is not required.

use Path::IsDev is_dev => { set => 'Basic' };
use Path::IsDev is_dev => { set => 'SomeOtherSet' , -as => 'is_dev_other' };

Overriding the default set

If for whatever reason the Basic set is insufficient, or if it false positives on your system for some reason, the "default" set can be overridden.

export PATH_ISDEV_DEFAULT_SET="SomeOtherSet"

...
use Path::IsDev qw( is_dev );
is_dev('/some/path') # uses SomeOtherSet

Though this will only take priority in the event the set is not specified during import

If this poses a security concern for the user, then this security hole can be eliminated by declaring the set you want in code:

export PATH_ISDEV_DEFAULT_SET="SomeOtherSet"

...
use Path::IsDev  is_dev => { set => 'Basic' };
is_dev('/some/path') # uses Basic, regardless of ENV

SECURITY

Its conceivable, than an evil user could construct an evil set, containing arbitrary and vulnerable code, and possibly stash that evil set in a poorly secured privileged users @INC

And if they managed to achieve that, if they could poison the privileged users %ENV, they could trick the privileged user into executing arbitrary code.

Though granted, if you can do either of those 2 things, you're probably security vulnerable anyway, and granted, if you could do either of those 2 things you could do much more evil things by the following:

export PERL5OPT="-MEvil::Module"

So with that in understanding, saying this modules default utility is "insecure" is mostly a bogus argument.

And to that effect, this module does nothing to "lock down" that mechanism, and this module encourages you to NOT force a set, unless you NEED to, and strongly suggests that forcing a set for the purpose of security will achieve no real improvement in security, while simultaneously reducing utility.

AUTHOR

Kent Fredric <kentnl@cpan.org>

COPYRIGHT AND LICENSE

This software is copyright (c) 2017 by Kent Fredric <kentfredric@gmail.com>.

This is free software; you can redistribute it and/or modify it under the same terms as the Perl 5 programming language system itself.